US Navy Settles Discrimination Claim by Blind Employee

US Navy Settles Discrimination Claim by Blind Employee

Educational Assistant to Receive $100,000

Image of page 1 of press release

Mary Carla Flood had worked for the United States Department of the Navy as an Educational Technician for only a day and a half when she was summarily fired. She had done nothing wrong, but human resources officials felt constrained by the results of her physical. That physical had revealed that she was legally blind, a fact that was obvious to the personnel who hired her on the spot at her job interview (Ms. Flood sometimes uses a white cane to navigate, and reads with reading glasses or uses large print). But the physician, based on the Navy’s medical certification form requiring all Educational Technicians to have “normal vision in both eyes,” as well as to have both hands and both legs, recommended Ms. Flood be terminated.

The Navy has now settled the discrimination suit that Ms. Flood brought after her firing. A significant factor in the settlement negotiations was the expert report of Carla McQuillan, a blind Montessori teacher and owner of Montessori schools. “I have been in this field since 1980 and have observed countless blind and visually impaired individuals work in childcare and early education settings, not to mention my own direct experience. There is absolutely no evidence that blind and visually impaired childcare workers and early education specialists are any less competent or safe than those who are not blind or visually impaired,” said McQuillan. 

Ms. Flood will receive $100,000, and the Navy has also agreed to enter into discussions with the National Federation of the Blind, which assisted Ms. Flood with her case, to develop nondiscriminatory employment practices with respect to blind people.

“By far the greatest barriers to the employment of blind people are low expectations and misconceptions about our abilities,” said Mark Riccobono, President of the National Federation of the Blind. “In spite of its legal obligation to implement affirmative action to hire employees with disabilities, the United States Navy is clearly trying to avoid hiring qualified individuals with disabilities. The National Federation of the Blind knows that blindness is not the characteristic that defines blind people, and we seek to convey this truth to all employers. We look forward to working with the Navy to ensure that its current and future blind employees do not experience discriminatory treatment.”

“When I was hired by the Navy on the spot, I was thrilled and excited to have a full-time job working with children. But when the Navy then fired me just as quickly because they just assumed blind and visually impaired people could not work with children, it was absolutely devastating.  I am relieved that this case has settled and my rights have been vindicated,” said Mary Carla Flood.

Flood has been represented by Scott LaBarre of LaBarre Law Offices P.C. and Eve Hill of Brown Goldstein and Levy LLP.

View press release PDF.